Episode 425 - Situations vs. Problems

Transcript:

Pete: Hey, Jen.

Jen: Hello, Peter.

Pete: I've got something for you, from the latest Seth Godin book. He's done it again, I guess. He's done it again.

Jen: I'm actually really excited to hear you talk about this, because my copy arrived yesterday and I have not cracked it open yet. So, I'm looking forward to the thought appetizers that are about to come my way.

Pete: I'll come your way. I'll do my best. I mean, no one will articulate this as good as Seth. But I feel like you'll have some good ideas and we could unpick it a little bit. What I want to talk to you about is this idea from Seth's new book, The Knot, and that is a situation versus a problem, or the difference between situations and problems.

Jen: Alright, let's do it. This is The Long and The Short Of It.

Jen: So, Seth's new book is called The Knot. K-N-O-T. I feel like I just needed to say that, for our listeners.

Pete: It's funny you say that, because I'm 83% through the audiobook. (And I have the hard copy as well, because I like to have hard copies.) And it's Seth narrating, himself. And maybe it's an accent thing, maybe it's my Australian ear, but he talks about knotty problems, as in K-N-O-T-T-Y. And I keep hearing "naughty", like N-A-U-G-H-T-Y.

Jen: Oh, that's so funny.

Pete: And I'm like, "Naughty problems, what? What's that got to do with it? Oh, knotty problems. Knotty problems." A quirk of the audiobook, versus reading the text. I'm like, "What's he talking about?" Yes. So, The Knot. I don't want to try and paraphrase this book too much because I just think it's worth going out and reading or, I mean, even listening to a podcast of Seth talk about it. But his point is, as far as I can interpret it, we all walk around dealing with these situations and / or problems where we feel stuck, like we're caught in a knot. And he has this really great story, as Seth always does, at the start, that kind of talks about this famous example of Alexander untying a literal knot, way back in the good ol' days. And the point is this guy, Alexander, approached the knot in a very different way than anyone else. He found this thing in the center called a pin. And he undid the pin, and the knot unfurled. So, that's kind of the rough premise of the book. But what he builds into off that is there is a difference between...and this is what I want to talk to you about. There is a difference between situations and problems. Situations versus problems. And so, if you think about it, a situation is something that you cannot change. A situation might be, Seth uses the undisputable examples like gravity or aging, as an example. They are situations. They are things that happen that we cannot control or govern. And so, we shouldn't spend energy trying to solve them, trying to fix them, trying to wish that we were twenty-five when we're thirty-five or wish that we were fifty when we're sixty. Because it's like, that's not going to happen. You're not going to pump...I mean, as I'm saying that, I'm like, there's like a movement to reverse aging. So, maybe people are trying to solve that as a situation. But anyway, for the most part, these are situations that you can't control. And what Seth kind of hints at is that so often, we get caught up, as humans, in situations, lamenting them, thrashing on them, getting annoyed about them, when it's not worth our time. And / or we think about a problem, which is more like something that can be solved with the right effort, energy, people, approach, innovation, whatever. And we might think of the problem as being a situation and give up, when actually it could be the kind of thing that we could solve if we approach it in a certain way. So, that's the rough premise and idea. I feel like I did a 60% job compared to how Seth would articulate it. Is that enough for you to understand, and wrap your head around, and ask questions, and throw this around?

Jen: Yes. So, I'm immediately sparked by a lot of this. The first thing that feels like it's important to say, and tell me if I am wrong, is that it's important that even though we can't solve situations, we understand them. Because the situation is the context in which the problem exists.

Pete: Boom. Yes. You nailed it. The situation might provide the constraints and the reality for which the problem sits within, so it requires an acknowledgement and like an acceptance of what it is. So you need to go, "Oh, here is the situation. I can accept that that's the situation, that they're the parameters I'm working with, the constraints. Now, let me look at the problem inside that."

Jen: Right. Okay. So this might go a little Insider Baseball for a moment, but what you've just described is one of the most important script analysis filters for actors, is being able to understand the difference between the situation (or what we would call "given circumstances"), and then the action of the play, which is people getting into problems and trying to solve them. But all of that exists within the context of the given circumstances of the play, the things that just are.

Pete: I bet Seth knew this, by the way. Pete didn't. That's so cool. Yeah. So this is a script analysis technique, okay. So what can we learn from script analysis about solving problems within situations, that's worth enlightening me about and the listeners?

Jen: Well, I think one of the benefits of being well-versed in identifying given circumstances is that you just accept them. Like, you don't fight them. Because if you fight the given circumstances, then the play ultimately doesn't make sense. So the situation, or the circumstance, or whatever words in Seth's book, the situations, the immovable situations that just are what they are, provide structure for everything else to exist in. But once you start trying to change them, the structure kind of falls apart.

Pete: Yeah. You get stuck in a knot.

Jen: Right. A K-N-O-T.

Pete: K-N-O-T. It's a knotty problem. Yeah. So I feel like, for me, it's: With a situation, how quickly can you get to acceptance? Because if you can get to acceptance, then you can get to looking at where your agency lies, what problem you can solve, what energy you could spend in which direction, because you've acknowledged and accepted the situation that is outside your control or that you're operating within. So it's like, for me, I mentioned this on a couple of episodes recently, I saw Ryan Holiday speak here in Brisbane. And he was sort of sharing some ideas from some of the books that he's written. And he talked about this idea of like, when he thinks about stoicism, it's not about not grieving, it's not about not reacting, it's not about not giving yourself permission to be emotional. It's: How quickly can you get back? It's making space for that, acknowledging that. And then, how quickly can you get back to, "Okay. Now, what's within my given circumstances that I can control? How can I focus on the things that are making me live a healthy, happy life?" So it's like this acceptance of how quickly can you accept your given circumstances, so that you can give yourself agency to move forward.

Jen: Okay. Can we just circle the word "acceptance" for a second? Because I feel myself have a reaction to "acceptance".

Pete: Yeah, I could see it in your face. She's looking at me like, "Don't say that word, Pete."

Jen: No, no, no. I feel like we just need to unpack it. Because when you say "acceptance" (I don't want to put words in your mouth, but here I go), you don't mean inviting, you don't mean welcoming, you don't mean embracing, you don't mean being satisfied by. I think what you're saying is acknowledging it is so.

Pete: "Acknowledging" is probably an even better word. I think it's just, yeah, exactly, accepting that it is or acknowledging that it just is. It's not good. It's not bad. It's not something in between. It just is. I can accept that this just is. I think about it on the global scale. If you think about the start of 2020, when COVID started happening and all of the things that happened as a result of that, there was a difference between organizations that accepted those given circumstances and quickly moved into what problem can we solve / how can we get our people to work remotely and from home, and blah, blah, blah, versus the organizations that failed to accept that that was the reality and then scrambled later on to do all the things that people had already done. I guess you can still think, "This is a bit shit," in your acceptance, but you also accept that it's a situation. "I accept that I cannot control this. I acknowledge that I cannot control this." I like the word "acknowledge". That maybe is a better word.

Jen: I don't know why this just popped into my mind, Pete, but are you familiar with...it's a super famous scene here in America, I don't know if it's famous across the pond...the pivot scene, from Friends? I can tell from the look on your face that you're not sure.

Pete: No, I paused because I feel like I should know. Friends was very much a cultural phenomenon in Australia, perhaps not as much so, I'm sure, as if you were living in New York. But it was and is, in the same way that Seinfeld was and is, even though we're on the other side of the world. I'm just trying to picture that exact scene. Describe it to me. What happened?

Jen: Okay. So what happens, Ross buys a couch. And so, the situation is that the stairwell is built the way the stairwell is built. The dimensions are not adjustable. And he and Chandler and Rachel attempt to get this sofa up this stairwell. And they can't, because the dimensions don't work. And he keeps screaming, "Pivot!" Just for some reason, that scene, to me, feels like an example of someone trying to solve a problem within the context of a situation that is immovable.

Pete: Or solve a situation. Because it's not a problem. It can't be solved. If it can't be solved, it's a situation.

Jen: Right.

Pete: That's the perfect example.

Jen: Oh my gosh.

Pete: It's so funny. And you know, blood, sweat, tears, frustration, all of this wasted energy because you were trying to solve a situation.

Jen: Yes.

Pete: I absolutely love that. It's such a funny example.

Jen: Well, isn't it ironic that Friends is a situation comedy? It's a sitcom.

Pete: Woah, you just blew my mind a little bit. Is that what "sitcom" stands for? Situation?

Jen: Yes.

Pete: I had no idea. I literally didn't know that.

Jen: Yeah, that the situations that the characters find themselves in are funny.

Pete: Alright, my life has just changed. I'll never look at a sitcom the same again. There you go. I'm a little bit shook about that. I didn't know that. I literally had no idea about that. Okay. So, in one of the interviews I heard Seth talking about this new book...I'm sure he phrased it like this. I just wrote it down like this. He asked a question in a very Seth way, which was something like, "So your job is to figure out, where does gravity end?" I interpret that as you need to figure out where the line is between a situation now becoming a problem, something you can do something about it, something that is worth your energy and your agency. And I interpreted that as, yeah, where is my agency? Or where does my agency begin? Because the flip side to trying to solve a situation that can't be solved, I think, is not taking ownership for a problem that you probably can solve if you so dared, but actually going, "No, I can't solve that because it's too hard," and you want to convince yourself it's a situation. It's, "Jen needs to be able to help me with this. I can't control what Jen does." So I talk myself into something being a situation, when actually we've got more agency than we realize, which is so much of what Seth Godin talks about. How can you see where that line is, and lean into the problem to solve?

Jen: Okay. I'm going back to the stairwell for a second, because I think I'm starting to understand this a little bit more. The situation is the size and shape of the stairwell. The problem is that Ross bought the wrong size couch. And he could solve the problem by getting a different couch. But he cannot change the situation of the size and shape of the stairwell.

Pete: Beautiful. So where gravity ends is, I guess, the size of the couch. The couch is the end point. Now, you have agency to decide, will you solve this problem, getting something comfortable for you to sit on in your apartment by choosing a different path, by choosing a different couch?

Jen: Okay. It's clearer for me now.

Pete: Great. Great, great, great. I mean, I feel called out. And I look at this through the lens of someone who is pretty good at overthinking things.

Jen: [laughing]

Pete: That's a knowing laugh of someone who knows me too well. There's so many life things on my horizon: moving cities, having another baby. I mean, that's enough, in and of itself. And there's a whole bunch of other stuff thrown in amongst that. And there's situations at the moment, that having a second child is not a problem to be solved. And yet, you can sit around and spend so much time and energy going, "Well, then the baby's going to come. And what are we going to do? We can drive here and there, and do this." And you just ruminate on the thing that's happening. When actually, there's probably problems that are within that situation that are worth my energy. "Have we got the movers organized? Have we got the insurance ready?" There are actually things I should channel my energy towards. So I'm seeing this so much in my life, where I am worrying about a situation or thinking about a situation and not looking for the problem enough that's within that.

Jen: So, what are the characteristics that define a problem? Does Seth give a definition of "problem" in this book?

Pete: My memory of it, I don't have it in front of me, is a problem is something that has a solution, i.e. you can take action to change the outcome. To me, that was the very distinct difference. Now, it doesn't mean that you're going to like it. It doesn't mean that there's not going to be discomfort. It doesn't mean that everyone will be happy. But as far as I remember it, he defines a problem as something where there's a solution. And so, that's where I think about this word "agency". It means you can do something. You can take action to change the outcome. In a situation, it's the opposite. It can't be changed or solved. And that's why he talks about gravity and aging as universal, undisputed examples...or the width of a stairwell in New York.

Jen: Okay. This reminds me of something I learned from Daniel Pink. I wrote a blog post about it. I'll drop it in the Box O' Goodies. And it's essentially misrepresenting a problem as a situation. And so, the gist is that if there's something you want to have or do in your life, and there is some sort of roadblock, sometimes people talk about things in this way. They'll say, "I want a new job, but I have eleven more months on my contract." Period. So they've taken what is a problem, "I want a new job." But by saying, "But I have eleven more years," hopefully not years, "eleven months on my contract," they have reframed it as a situation. And so, what Daniel Pink suggests is that you cut the "but", you change it to "and". And then, you take away the period, add a comma, and add the word "so". So it becomes, "I want a new job, and I have eleven months left on my contract, so fill-in-the-blank." And this is a way to move yourself into problem solving, rather than situation accepting.

Pete: Oh, so, so beautifully said. Seth talks about changing "buts" to "ands" as a way to drive more problem solving agency. I do love the reminder, though, to add the "so" at the end of that.

Jen: Right.

Pete: That is genius. Give yourself a next step. Give yourself a thing to do off the back of it. Brilliant. Absolutely brilliant.

Jen: I want this podcast to go on forever, and we're kind of at the twenty-minute mark, so we'll wrap it up for now, knowing that next week, there will be another episode.

Pete: And that is The Long and The Short Of It.